read the following claim and counterclaim from an essay: claim: cell phones may cause brain cancer…
read the following claim and counterclaim from an essay: claim: cell phones may cause brain cancer. counterclaim: medical research has not yet proven a connection between brain cancer and cell phone use. which of the following is the most relevant rebuttal to the counterclaim? a. cell phones are not a necessity, so people could learn to moderate use in case their health is at risk. b. medical research usually takes a long time before it proves anything. c. while the data from medical research hasnt proven anything conclusively, an increasing number of studies indicate that there is a significant risk. d. even though they cannot prove the case for cancer yet, is being glued to a radioactive device 24 hours a day really smart?
Answer
Brief Explanations:
The counter - claim is that medical research has not proven a connection. Option C acknowledges the lack of conclusive proof but points to an increasing number of studies indicating a significant risk, directly rebutting the counter - claim. Option A is about cell phone necessity and moderation, not about the research connection. Option B just mentions the time it takes for medical research to prove something, not addressing the current indication of risk. Option D is more of a rhetorical question about the wisdom of constant cell phone use rather than a direct response to the research - based counter - claim.
Answer:
C. While the data from medical research hasn't proven anything conclusively, an increasing number of studies indicate that there is a significant risk.